top of page

2

(nothing substantial)

6

(some violence and mild sexual innuendo)

7

(worth seeing many times)

"Batman" to this day remains one of my favorite superhero to screen adaptations. Part of that comes from the comics being among my favorites to read. I’ve been fascinated with Batman for a long time even to the point of writing a highly-praised college term paper comparing his world to Greek mythology.

 

Tim Burton and his crew managed to capture much of what I most enjoy about the character. Bruce Wayne deals with death by staring it in the eye every night and stopping it wherever he can. Other heroes do that to some extent, but with a character as powerful as the Hulk or Superman the challenges are generally harder to relate to. Batman can’t throw cars, leap over buildings, or stop a train with his hands -- his primary weapons are his intelligence and training sometimes to the point of being portrayed as a Sherlock Holmes type character.

 

The mystery stories were always my favorites when reading the books. The movie doesn’t have that much mystery, but it does portray Batman’s detective skills and has the dark, gothic atmosphere inspired by the detective’s late-night investigations. It also deals with the character nicely.

 

Say what you will about Michael Keaton, but he captured the essence of Batman with a dose of realism. Batman is intense, precise, and brilliant. However, he’s obsessed, and an obsessed man is bound to have some drawbacks in his life. As Bruce he’s a bit absent-minded. It’s difficult for him to say what he wants to say, and he definitely needs Alfred’s help to put on the air of the socialite his cover requires him to be. To an unsuspecting looker-on he might seem to be a careless playboy, but we know he’s got bigger things on his mind.

 

While I enjoy the animated Bruce who is the consummate businessman and who can add oration to his list of skills, this movie version gives us a Bruce that is not flawless yet still very much super-heroic. Keaton also gives us a Batman who has the intensity but not necessarily the physicality to be imposing. His costume is an important part of his equation to psyche out his opponents, calculated to be recognizable and fearsome. The costume is designed to make up for what he would otherwise lack in his ability to intimidate his adversaries.

 

The Joker… an insane prankster clown. Sounds pretty lame doesn’t it? He has no powers, he’s got a permanent grin, and his face is greasepaint white. I mean are they serious? Yet he is one of the most fearsome villains ever. Strange villains are a dime a dozen so what makes him so much better? For one thing he’s not putting on a clown costume to be the Joker, he’s actually disfigured. He’s not driven by greed or the desire to blow up the world, he’s a true sociopath. He’s looking for amusement, and his lethal pranks are fun for him. He’s Batman’s nemesis because of his brilliance, warped though it might be.

 

Two-Face, Riddler, and others can be dangerous but are to some degree predictable. Figure out the Riddler’s puzzle, exploit Harvey’s duality, smack the Penguin. Joker is more dangerous than any of the others. With the possible exception of Harley (and what evil clown wouldn’t want the likes of HER around??? Maybe in a future movie…) he might at any time have an exploding whoopee cushion or joy buzzer of death waiting for the next guy that says something he doesn’t like.

 

In addition to Joker being a great villain, I enjoy the ferocity with which Nicholson plays the part. Seeing the betrayal that leads to his transformation and the believable (from a characterization standpoint at least) roots of his insanity adds a layer on which Nicholson is able to build a disturbing intelligence and disdain for normalcy. The depths of his dark humor are frightening. "The Killing Joke" has long been one of my favorite Batman stories. I quickly saw the similarities between it and the movie. It was only recently that I learned that this, more than any other single story, directly influenced the movie. There’s a dark humor there as well as an attention to characters that sets "Batman" apart from standard action or super-hero movies.

 

The costume and props have gone through many redesigns over the years. It’s no surprise that the movie would want its own style. This costume is rubber with the practical use of body armor. The car is low to the ground and sharp. Years later it's still one of the best designs ever. There’s a gothic look to everything which seems to be what Batman would want. It doesn't quite have all the practical technology of the Dark Knight movies, but it's much more than a costume for the sake of a costume.

 

The story is in some ways exactly what you might expect from the cinema treatment: facing off with a villain that culminates into a final battle while creating more personal ties: love interest, love interest conflict with the villain, and oh-no-Batman-might-be-dead (yeah right). There is one thing that is different from most other super hero movies, in that it does not begin with Batman’s origins. That’s not to say they aren’t revealed, but when we first meet Bruce he’s already Batman. Don’t get me wrong, I love seeing the lives of Peter Parker pre-Spider-Man and Clark Kent pre-Superman, but it’s nice to get a different pace.

 

My one big complaint here is that Batman doesn't seem as worried about the preservation of life as he does in many other incarnations. He will beat up and subdue criminals, but he is not a killer. Take a scene from the "Arkham Asylum" game, for an example. A thug falls down into Joker's toxic gas prompting Batman to say for the benefit of the player, “I can't let that man die.” If you don't save him you can't advance to the next part of the game. This is exactly how I think of Bats. Keaton's Batman is less concerned about such things even to the point of blowing up a building that presumably has people still inside it.

 

Everything about this production is outstanding, and that includes the score. While there are many good things about the newer Dark Knight movies, they can't live up to this iconic score (of which I own 2 different versions on CD). Danny Elfman’s theme is the most recognizable super-hero theme since John Williams’ Superman. I enjoy a lot of soundtracks, and this one is near the top of the list of the best ever. The songs by Prince (who may or may not be going by that name when you read this) got old fast even though I liked them as a kid, but for the most part they work within the context of the movie. I'm glad they dialed Prince down in favor of Elfman.

 

All in all this is a great balance of realism and comic book lore. It's still a little campy for some people, it definitely has less of the realism found in the Dark Knight series and has a more classic comic book feel mixed with a little of Burton's dark fairy tale style. It's far more gothic and modern than the old Adam West series so it doesn't take a comic book nerd like myself to appreciate it, but as a comic book nerd partial to Batman I love it.

Morality

Even though this is PG13 it's quite mild for its rating which probably has a lot to do with Joker's cruelty such as frying a man to a charred husk and then having a comical conversation with it. Several people are killed in cold blood by the criminals, there is some disfiguring by acid, and we hear about a girl driven to suicide thanks to abusive treatment.

 

Fighting is prevalent but it's primarily comic book style with little blood and few onscreen deaths. Even so a couple of moments are dark and potentially disturbing.

 

Strong language is mild and infrequent.

 

Sexuality is also mild the most notable of it being a steamy but fully-clothed moment between Bruce and Vicki. Sex is implied but not depicted.

Spirituality

"Batman" seems to want to avoid any notion of religion at all. It's perhaps a little easier in Gotham than some other settings since none of these people have any kind of supernatural powers. They may be super versions of humans in what they can do, but they are still strictly mortal.

 

Despite what I said about this Batman not exhibiting the same concern about the preservation of life as other incarnations of the character there is still a huge difference between him and the villains. If Batman kills it is typically incidental (with a couple of arguable exceptions), he never exhibits a desire to take life. He puts his life on the line and uses his vast resources to help other people which of course is a good thing.

 

Batman can be a bit dark compared to many popular super heroes. He typically operates in the shadows and relies more on fear and intimidation than many of his fellow heroes. Joker is a sadistic kind of guy and can be gruesome even for a murderous villain. As a result some younger kids (and perhaps others as well) don't take to Bats as they take to some of the other heroes, but he's still very much heroic – perhaps even one of the most so.

Final Thoughts

I love "Batman" and I love this portrayal even though I would like to see his stance against taking life have a stronger presentation. While "The Dark Knight" is my favorite Batman movie, this one still ranks high and is easily one of my favorite movies of the late 80's – early 90's. If you are looking for some super hero action and don't mind it being a little more classic comic book style than ultra-modern dramatic realism you should most definitely check this out.

Buying Guide

Tim Burton's first "Batman" movie has seen numerous releases over the years. There's a variety of DVD and high-def options which I hope to help you sort out below. Keep in mind that by the time you read this it is entirely possible that they have repackaged or re-released it yet again.

 

All 4 of the 90's Batman movies have a few different solo and combo options, but they come in 2 basic varieties: an older print and newer remaster. The older one is bare-bones offered on a solo DVD and as part of a 4 pack.

 

The newer remaster typically comes in a 2-disc DVD Special Edition or Blu-ray. There is an Anthology box set for both formats and at least 1 combo for the Blu. While it's entirely possible that there is, or will be, a DVD combo of the remaster I have yet to see one. If you're not sure about the difference between the combo and box set distinctions the box set looks like you bought each movie then put them all in a Batman box while the combo looks more like you condensed everything into a Batman mix tape. The Blu is also included in the Tim Burton Collection box set. And finally there is the 20th Anniversary Edition which is only available on Blu by itself.

 

If you want to know a few more details about the various versions out there read on. If you want to get on to the contents of the disc jump down to the next section.

 

The Original Print:

The older DVD is mostly bare-bones though it may offer some production notes as an extra. The video is 1.85 widescreen with 5.1 surround sound. I have read that the quality is awful. The combo DVD that offers this version is a 2 disc set and therefore probably includes double-sided DVD's (1 movie per side).

 

The Remaster:

The Blu-rays list everything that I will describe below on the Special Edition DVD versions (no Blu-ray exclusive features, in other words). The main difference, of course, is the HD quality: 1.85 16x9 widescreen presentation at 1080p with 5.1 Dolby True HD sound. I have to caution you, though, several reviews have said that the actual quality is not as impressive as one might think. Even if that's true the new transfer already looks good just on DVD.

 

The Anthology box set would, as I'm sure you can surmise, look like you bought all 4 movies on Blu and put them in a Batman box.

 

The Blu combo repackages everything but appears to include the same specs and extras as the regular Blus. Assuming the info listed is correct you'll only miss out on some of the nicer original packaging but get all of the same content.

 

Other Blu Options:

The 20th Anniversary edition Blu comes with a book that is a part of the disc case. It is reportedly 50 pages and includes recreations of the original making-of book along with some script and comic pages. I don't think this book is available anywhere else though some of the content obviously is. The contents of the disc look the same as the other releases.

 

The Tim Burton box set also sounds like it's the exact same version as the standard Blu, though, of course, I can't confirm that since I don't have it. The main difference is that this box set comes with a book that includes details about each movie. Is it different than the content of the 20th Anniversary book? As far as I can tell, yes. Multiple reviews have expressed amazement of the high quality of this book.

 

Final Recommendation:

If you're a Batman fan the Special Edition DVD's are very well done and offer a lot for your money. If you have even a mild interest in DVD extras and like this movie you should consider adding "Batman" to your shelf. This is even more of a consideration if you want to see all 4 of the movies and all that each one has to offer. If you are wanting only this first movie (or are just that dedicated a fan) the 20th Anniversary is worth a look for the exclusive book it offers, and if you're specifically looking for Tim Burton movies the Blu box set of his various movies sounds like a good buy. If I ever do upgrade my "Batman" and "Batman Returns" DVD's to Blu it will be because I broke down and got that collection. The Anthology box set was a good bargain in the past (far better than buying the movies individually), and the Blu combo pack is a good deal if you don't care about having the Anthology packaging. Go for the old bare-bones DVD only if you have no self respect as a DVD collector.

The Special Edition DVD is a 2 disc set and is the same whether you get it by itself or in the 4 movie box set.

 

Video

1.85 widescreen:

There's no way in Gotham this is going to look as good as the 1080p presentation, but if Blu isn't an option I doubt you will have any complaints about the image quality. It is a new transfer and really looks good.

Audio

5.1 Dolby and 5.1 DTS:

The sound is clean, clear, and rich. Again, it's not HD quality, but stacked up against other DVD's it sounds quite good.

 

Packaging

I love the Batman cover art from the Tim Burton movies and therefore love the look of these DVD cases. There's a unity to the look of the Special Edition movies' art.

 

The case itself is standard plastic.

 

The only complaint I have about this edition is that it has no insert. I like chapters lists and a little bit of printed material with my DVD’s. I can overlook the lack of them with the $5 bargain bin DVD’s, but a big release like this one should have something.

 

The interface isn’t particularly creative, but it does have animation and audio which is better than a plain page.

 

Extras

-Commentary: Tim Burton: Tim is a better director than he is a speaker. He has some interesting ideas but they are presented in a stumbling and interrupted way making it difficult to follow sometimes.

 

-Theatrical Trailer (1:47) Somewhat unusual in that there is no announcer, it's just a string of clips. It could use some unifying background music.

 

-History of Batman (40:35) This is part of a series called "Legends of the Dark Knight." This is an interesting look at the beginning and development of the charater. It's a great documentary hosted by Mark Hamill and including a number of recognizable names, some of whom you may not realize are associated with the Dark Knight.

 

-On the Set with Bob Kane (2:32) Bob shares his thoughts about the movie. It feels cut off at the end, but is otherwise worth watching.

 

-Shadows of the Bat (This is a behind-the-scenes series that will continue through the following 3 movie releases. There's a play all option for the group):

 -The Road to Gotham City (17:43) The early days of the movie concept and why these people wanted to make it. It includes the story of comics coming to college campuses, comments from Stan Lee, and a comparison between Superman and Moses.

 -The Gathering Storm (22:57) Developing and refining the vision, the question of Robin, Tim Burton's influence, and the silly choice of Michael Keaton.

 -The Legend Reborn (30:57) What the production was like from the perspective of the cast and crew.

 

-The Heroes (These are character profiles that take a look at the history and motivations of the key players. There's a play all option.):

            -Batman (4:53) Who he is, where he comes from, and how that translates into a serious film.

            -Vivki Vale (1:55) What she's like and why whe's important.

            -Alexander Knox (1:36) Why he's in the story and what his fate was supposed to be.

            -Commissioner Gordon (1:54) His relationship with Batman.

            -Harvey Dent (2:11) Looking ahead to Two-Face.

 

The Villains (More character profiles. There's a play all option once again.):

            -The Joker (4:59) Who he is and thoughts on his new origin.

            -Bob the Goon (2:19) Casting the role and the character's thoughts on the Joker.

 

-Beyond Batman (Another series of behind-the-scenes clips mostly covering the more technical aspects. It has it's own play all option):

            -Visualizing Gotham (10:24) This is about production design with thoughts on the artist, the aesthetic, and the looks of various sets.

            -Building the Batmobile (9:22) Developing the design and building a drivable version.

            -Those Wonderful Toys (6:02) All about the props and gadgets with a few close-up looks.

            -Designing the Batsuit (6:57) The importance of the suit, finding the form and function, and the challenge of the cape.

            -From Jack to The Joker (10:37) Jack's appreciation of the Joker and finding a way to get the look while not losing the actor.

            -Nocturnal Overtures (7:04) About the music – getting Danny involved and his approach to tones and motifs.

 

-The Complete Robin Storyboard Sequence (4:23) A storyboard shows how the writers explored the idea of the introduction of Robin. It has simple animation and music and the cast of the animated series as the voices (including Conroy and Hamill). It’s pretty interesting to see what might have been. A text intro gives some additional details.

 

-Music Videos (3 videos by Prince with a play all option):

-Partyman (3:59) Energetic and featuring some good Joker visuals.

-Scandalous (4:16) A terrible song and a boring video. Sorry, Prince fans. How it became the pop-sound for such an otherwise great production is beyond me.

-Batdance (6:57) A weak song but with some great visuals - the dancers made up to be half Batman half Joker suggest a new spin on the duality of super heroes and villains. These songs seem to me like they fit the production of "Batman Forever" better than they do this one and vice-versa for “Kiss From a Rose.”

 

-Web Info: A page with a couple of web addresses and some copyright info.

 

 

The full title of the box set is "Batman" The Motion Picture Anthology 1989-1997." It includes the 4 Batman movies from during that time. Each one of those is a 2 disc set.

 

Packaging

Each disc has its own case. They fit into a large box that looks quite nice.

 

Extras

The Anthology box set does not offer any additional extras for the collection, but each release is loaded.

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page