top of page

2

(nothing direct)

6

(strong language, sexual humor)

5

(worth seeing once)

I thought "Short Circuit" was the greatest movie ever when it came out. Okay, that's not entirely true, it was crap on the bottom of my shoe compared to "Star Wars," but without that standard of measure it was pretty darn good. Half a lifetime later it's not quite so impressive. Oh, it's still entertaining, but not nearly at the level of my youthful enthusiasm.

 

Newton is master of robotics who has built impressively functional robotic soldiers. These things have terrific firepower and the artificial intelligence needed to make targeting and combat decisions without human control. An electrical surge gives one of them life. Disoriented, robot number 5 finds himself on a truck that takes him off the base and ultimately to the rural house of Stephanie. Thankfully Stephanie, an animal lover with boyfriend troubles, is very open-minded and welcomes the "alien" in rather than freaking out.

 

#5 (who later names himself Johnny) already has a sense of morality, but he’s essentially a newborn in every other way. He learns about life and death and their importance. He does not want to take life as he was designed to do, and he's afraid that if his creators get a hold of him they will dismantle - as in KILL - him. Johnny and Stephanie must convince Newton that this robot is truly alive, and that taking him apart to determine the "malfunction" would be a bad thing.

 

Meanwhile, Stephanie and Newton being a distrustful courtship. Neither one of them is particularly good with the opposite sex, and the oddity of their situation doesn’t help, yet they are, for no good reason to be perfectly honest, drawn together like magnets.

 

The comedy comes mostly from Johnny who has an innocent and straight-forward perspective. He does things robots just don't do like imitating a gangster and turning other robots into 3 Stooges characters. Yet he does things that aren’t common human behavior like taking figures of speech literally. His odd vocabulary and logic paths are fun to watch.

 

The other big helping of funny comes from Ben, Newton’s assistant and confidant, who has a thick accent and a funny way of speaking, often innocently saying things he doesn't mean such as telling Newton their outing will be a good opportunity to "spread his legs" when he actually mean "stretch." These aren't quite as funny as they were when I was younger, but they still tend to be amusing.

 

Besides the comedy not being quite so funny now, my real disappointment is with Steve Guttenberg. I just don't think he makes a particularly believable geek. I mean this guy is supposed to be married to his robotics and completely oblivious to wooing a woman, but I don't buy into any of it. Tobey Maguire knows how to play a geek, Steve just doesn’t nail it.

 

Ben (Fisher Stevens) is an unbelievable character, but he's so far off the wall that it works pretty well for the comedy aspect. Stephanie (Ally Sheedy) is definitely the best as far as a believable character. Something of a social outcast but with a girl-next-door beauty about her she comes across as a desirable but quirky and always caring girl. She's cute but with an inner strength that comes out thanks to Johnny 5.

 

Tim Blaney (AKA Frank the pug if you saw Men in Black), is Johnny 5 and steals the show without question. He really feels like a human character in the same way Star Wars droids like C-3PO do. His speech patterns are weird, but his emotions and sense of humor come across nicely. He’s entertaining to watch.

 

G.W. Bailey, who acted with Steve in the Police Academy movies, plays a similar role here. He's memorable simply because it's who he is on screen so often, but his overzealous military lust for violence is flat and stereotypical.

 

In the end it's an uplifting story, one that will leave you feeling warm and fuzzy. It has its moments of tension as the military hunts down Johnny 5 to destroy him with an emotional moment or two. Otherwise it's light-hearted and funny almost from start to finish.

Morality

In most ways this is appropriate for younger audiences with the main issue being some strong language. A lot of it is unnecessary, and I'm bothered by the frequency with which they use the name of Jesus as an expletive.

 

A few of the jokes are sexual in nature but usually in the context of an inappropriate comment made innocently. Otherwise this is probably the cleanest movie Steve Guttenberg ever made.

 

There's a scene of Stephanie in the tub but it is not at all revealing. There's no sex and no actual violence despite the fact that there are a lot of guns going off. Even when Johnny has no choice but to attack he takes care not to hurt anyone.

Spirituality

While there is nothing directly spiritual outside of the misuse of the name of Jesus, there is a great emphasis put on the sanctity of life. Most of it comes from Johnny 5 whose predicament gives him an appreciation of all life. He is devastated when he accidentally kills a grasshopper and realizes that it can't be repaired like a machine. Life is precious, and that's a message that I appreciate.

 

At the same time I get the impression that life is so important in this story because there is nothing beyond it. This isn't stated specifically, but it's important for us as Christians to have the faith that as wonderful as this gift from God called life is, death is not the end for us. There is more ahead, and that is something missing from "Short Circuit."

Final Thoughts

This is a fun movie especially if you’re revisiting it from years gone by. It’s not a must see, though. As much as I enjoy the humor, there’s better out there, and some of the weak characters and acting hold back the movie a bit. I would view it as a great movie for parents to watch with kids if not for the strong language, but perhaps some older kids would get a kick out of a living, wise-cracking robot.

Buying Guide

The first “Short Circuit” took its sweet time to get a decent release. I'm not convinced that any of them are truly great, but at least a couple of them are way better than the one I got.

 

Image has 2 DVD's out. The older one is 2.40 widescreen while the newer ones is 2.35. I can't find any other difference between them based on product listings. There is a third version that is a Widescreen Special Edition.

 

It has since come out on Blu and there are 2-packs with the sequel in both formats.

 

Blu-ray:

The Blu offers 2.41 widescreen at 1080i (which is not as good as 1080p) with 5.1 HD DTS surround sound. The image quality is said to vary between decent to really bad. The audio track sounds like it will be better, maybe even almost impressive. Extras include the same stuff as the original DVD.

 

Other DVD's:

The older Image DVD may actually be better than the later re-release. For one thing it actually has extras including a commentary, music track, and some behind-the-scenes stuff. The non-anamorphic widescreen and surround sound details are the same as my edition.

 

The Special Edition DVD offers 2.35 widescreen and 5.1 Dolby surround sound. The extras mostly look like the earlier DVD. I couldn't find any comments on the quality, but unless it has been remastered since the one I got (there is nothing to signify that it has) I wouldn't expect much.

 

Collections:

The Blu 2 pack with the sequel is not even worth a glance. The listings I saw were so ridiculously overpriced that you could buy every individual edition of both movies and still pay less than this one double-feature which does not offer anything you can't get on the regular Blu.

 

The DVD 2 pack is more reasonable but appears to be bare-bones.

 

Final Recommendation:

Somehow I managed to end up with the only edition that doesn't include any extras. Way to go, me! With terrible quality on top of that this is one to avoid. Blu is definitely your best shot at any kind of decent quality, and even that lacks. If you can't do Blu go for the Special Edition DVD if at all possible. The other ones offer nothing and lack in quality. Avoid the Blu 2 pack unless you happen upon a more reasonable asking price than what I've been seeing. The DVD 2 pack might be worth it if you're looking for a deal on both movies without too much concern for the best quality or extra features.

Image has 3 DVD's out. This one is a re-release (the second of the 3) and is a single disc.

 

Video

N-A 2.35 widescreen:

So while the image is 2.35 widescreen it is non-anamorphic which means it is presented in a 1.33 (TV standard ratio) frame resulting in black bars on all 4 sides when viewing on a widescreen TV. It comes across like watching the film through a fence. It's fuzzy, grainy, smudgy, and dull. In just about every way it looks messy.

Audio

5.1 Dolby:

There's not much to the audio other than acceptable clarity and decent levels. There isn't much to the range with almost no bass. There is enough surround sound to be noticeable but nothing impressive.

 

Packaging

This one comes in a plastic case. 

 

The interface is a static image, but the graphics are amusing.

 

Extras

Jack squat.

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page