top of page

5

(supernatural interactions)

4

(nudity, sex, violence, disturbing images, strong language)

6

(worth seeing more than once)

"Stir Of Echoes" was one of the better horror movies I had seen in a while when it came out. It still remains one I revisit from time to time. I grew up watching Freddy and Jason hack people up, but now I prefer stories that don’t rely on the number of different ways people can be mauled in a 2 hour period. "Stir Of Echoes" is really more of a supernatural thriller\mystery in the vein of 6th Sense, but it has some great moments of fright.

 

We start with a normal blue-collar family. Well, almost normal. The 5 year old talks to dead people, and after an experiment with hypnosis so does the dad, only his experiences are far more disturbing. Tom, a person who didn't ascribe to paranormal mubo-jumbo, becomes a man obsessed with the mysteries of the dead. He must get them out of his head one way or another no matter the cost, and that may be everything he has including his life.

 

The first aspect that strikes me is the depiction of the family. They aren’t blissfully happy, and they aren’t facing divorce. They are a couple faced with the problems of life and working on it together. They are established and have come to the realization, as so many of us have, that they haven’t achieved all they want in life. It’s a far better portrayal of blue-collar family life than what I’ve seen in most movies.

 

The use of the supernatural is more subtle than in similar movies. There are some jolting and some disturbing moments, but the reliance is not on shock value. The ghost Tom sees, for example, is not all that gruesome. She’s made creepy by unnatural movements and human reactions rather than gore. Not that the breaking fingernail didn't make me cringe, but that's only part of the creepiness.

 

While the familial and ghostly elements are exceptionally well written, there are some flaws in the story. The psychic son is overused. I think the story could have been improved by tighter focus on Tom’s plight and interaction with the supernatural. I feel like this is his and the ghost's story yet the kid becomes the focus for periods of time. I won't say that the son's part of the story feels unimportant; Tom's increasingly weird interactions with him add a lot to the atmosphere, but neither does it feel like it should be as central as it sometimes comes across.

 

Also, the mystic clan feels out of place. A member of the group approaches the family and does give the wife some answers, but the secret meeting place scene just doesn't fit with the rest of the movie.

 

Kevin Bacon is outstanding. He really digs into this role to bring across the fatherly qualities and scared obsession. All of the acting is pretty good lending strength and credibility to the story, but Kevin's really stands out. The kid does a fairly good job in his role, although some of his scenes don’t feel natural. He has a strong 6th Sense Haley Joel Osment feel to him without being as good (perhaps why this one was overshadowed by the other). I keep expecting to hear him say, "I see dead people."

 

While not actually always scary, there is a great element of mystery and a solid creepy atmosphere that make this a DVD I get out regularly during the Halloween season. It might not be enough to keep you awake at night, but it might well give nightmares to the sensitive. If you don't particularly like horror movies you don't want to watch this one alone. 

Morality

There’s a good bit of strong language. F bombs and a number of other choice words are thrown around throughout.

 

Some of the images are violent and gruesome though not necessarily always gory. We see a tooth pulled in painful, bloody detail, a fingernail breaking in such a violent way that it makes me cringe, and disturbing images like a desiccated corpse. There really aren't very many violent scenes, but the ones we do get can be brutal.

 

There’s a graphically acted sex scene between Tom and his wife showing shots of her naked from the waist up. Later we see Maggie’s bare backside as she gets into the tub. The most disturbing is a violent attempt to molest a young girl though it never gets as far as clothes coming off.

Spirituality

Tom gets into this situation by playing around with spiritual forces he doesn't understand at the guidance of someone who is tries New Age type attempts at touching the spirit world. Think of it as someone messing around with a Ouija board and finding they've come into contact with real demonic forces.

 

This is a story that follows the conception that a person's spirit can be trapped on Earth after death especially if there is emotional turmoil involved. The spirit more or less has to complete some task before being capable of resting. In this reality some people are predisposed to being psychic which can lead them to interact with the dead, such as a medium, whether they want to or not. Nobody in this movie sets out to contact the dead, at least not until Tom becomes obsessed with what he has seen and tries to recreate the circumstances so he can find out more, but sometimes they can't help it. 

Final Thoughts

While not flawless "Stir of Echoes" is one of the better modern movies of its genre. Fans of classic ghost stories and supernatural thrillers should enjoy it. If your idea of horror is teens running around with a knife-wielding maniac trying to create blood pools large enough to swim in then you might find this one a bit boring.

Buying Guide

While multiple listings with varied cover art make buying "Stir Of Echoes" look harrowing, it's not as bad as it might seem at first.

 

There is a Blu available and at lease one double-feature (with "A Haunting in Connecticut"). It offers 1.78 widescreen at 1080p with 6.1 DTS HD surround sound. Comments on the quality suggest that this is sharp with good black levels but not completely clean and not especially impressive. The sound is reportedly solid with strong bass and decent surround sound immersion. The extras omit several of the ones available on DVD and offer nothing new. There's a commentary, “Sights of Spirits,” and deleted scenes.

 

I saw a variety of listings for DVD's, but upon closer examination there are actually only 2 releases. One is by Artisan and the other, a Special Edition, is offered by Lionsgate. There is at least 1 DVD box set which includes the sequel and a couple of other horror flicks.

 

I'll cover the Special Edition in detail below. The Artisan DVD offers widescreen with 5.1 Dolby surround sound. The extras listed are a short promo, a behind-the-scenes feature (which appears to be different from anything on the other DVD), the music video, 3 TV spots, and 3 hidden mini documentaries.

 

The DVD 4-pack set is from Lionsgate and most likely includes the extras from the Special Edition though I can't be certain.

 

Final Recommendation:

Which version you should get depends on what you want more. The Blu offers HD quality although it doesn't sound like it's up to the high standards of the best Blus. The Special Edition DVD offers a good bit more in the way of extras. The lack of some of these on the Blu is surprising and keeps me from giving it my full recommendation over the DVD. The Lionsgate transfer is probably superior to Artisan's even though it's not all that impressive.

The Lionsgate Special Edition is a single disc DVD.

 

Video

1.85 widescreen:

The image is a little grainy and a bit dull (which might be on purpose given the nature of the film). It's not impressive, but it is acceptable.

Audio

5.1 Dolby EX, 6.1 DTS ES Discrete:

The audio is clean with good bass tones. Surround sound immersion is pretty good.

 

Packaging

The case is the standard plastic fare. 

 

The insert has some very interesting artwork, some production notes, and a chapter list. 

 

The interface is creative.  It's disorienting at first but pulls the viewer into the movie before it even starts which is the mark of good DVD design.  Menu options are constantly shifting requiring a little effort to find the right choice.  The main menu choices are written backwards in a mirror and aren’t the standard labels for their functions.  To play the movie, for example, select “see.”  To go to the special features go to “dig” (which has a special significance from the movie).

 

Extras

 

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page