top of page

6

(several characters are devoted Christians)

4

(sex, a little nudity, strong lanugage, and graphic violence)

8

(it is powerful and breathtaking)

"Braveheart" is one of my favorite movies. Few movies are powerful enough to bring a tear to my eye every time, and this one never fails. A modern epic, it chronicles the life of William Wallace and the events that create in him a warrior influential enough to lay the course for Scotland to win its freedom from England.

 

Like life itself the movie is not pure tragedy, not pure comedy (in the Shakespearian sense), but traces of both in cyclical patterns. William faces joy followed by intense sorrow followed by triumph followed by more sorrow and on and on.

 

The story carries strong messages about everything that is noble: love, honor, loyalty, bravery, friendship, freedom. These themes combined with the impeccable filmmaking create a movie that everyone needs to see at least once. I come away feeling like I've experienced something real (which may have something to do with me watching so many movies with aliens and monsters so a movie about regular humans with no superpowers is a lot closer to real life than what I usually watch. Though if William Wallace were alive today he would probably be Batman.)

 

Part of what makes this movie great is the amount of factual content. Wallace is real, the events surrounding his wife are real; some artistic license is taken, and some of the material is based on legend rather than hard fact, but there’s a lot of history here. Whoa, there's that real-life element again. It's like looking at your hand and realizing it's in 3D... without the glasses (unless your eyesight sucks, or you're wearing Ray Bans, or... nevermind...)

 

Back to the reality of real life, "Braveheart" seeks to capture the imperfections of humanity as well as the courage and determination of its heroes. Heroes die, good people make bad decisions, friends disagree and get angry, strong men cry: the traditional Hollywood archetypes are largely abandoned. Wallace is not a typical summer blockbuster action movie hero like what Schwarzenegger usually plays.

 

This is not so much entertainment as it is a statement. It can actually be difficult to watch because it reminds the viewer of death and misery in the world, however it counters that with hope and the greatness of fighting for what is right. The battle scenes do a nice job of putting the viewer in the middle of the action. It’s easy to empathize when you see the bloody arrow sticking out of a man's flesh or the limb severed – things that make the viewer wince with sympathizing agony. This is graphic stuff.

 

What I find interesting is that most people tend to remember the evisceration scene as the most violent and graphic when the worst thing shown is ropes pulling on the victim. The rest is facial expression and music. The dismemberment scenes are far more graphic as far as actual blood, yet the implied scenes are the ones that stand out in memories. Such is the power of suggestion over depiction.

 

Speaking of music, James Horner does an exceptional job here especially if you like Celtic sounds. I own both soundtracks and love them. The music is as epic as the movie itself.

 

The acting here is some of the best I’ve ever seen. Every actor hits home, and it doesn’t take the likes of Mel Gibson to put a lump in your throat. A number of the actors feel like they're reaching inside your chest and squeezing your heart. The cast is far too large for me to go down the list especially since most aren't likely to be instantly recognizable, but I can't think of a single person who isn't exceptional.

 

The movie is nearly 3 hours long which was a bigger deal upon its release I guess since there weren't as many movies of that length showing back then. Not that I remember, at least. "The Lord of the Rings" movies make this one seem short these days. Despite its length, the movie does not drag at all. The exciting battles and moving drama are spaced perfectly.

Morality

There’s a little bit of nudity as Murron and William prepare to consummate their marriage. The Scottish army flashes their enemies. This practice, by the way, is taken from factual history, it’s not just an excuse to have a bunch of guys hike their kilts. It could have been worse since it was not unheard of for Scottish soldiers to go into battle wearing NOTHING but war paint. But anyway there are a few moments of flashed crotches (from a distance) and bared butts (one with an arrow sticking out of it).

 

The English sanction the raping of the Scottish women. Though we never actually see any scenes of this happening we see the women being taken.

 

The language is sometimes strong and crude with a number of F-bombs and other such words thrown around. It's perhaps not all that frequent for an R rated movie.

 

The violence is plenty graphic. Limbs are severed and heads are bashed in. While it could be seen as unnecessary it helps get across the seriousness of the war and the viciousness of the battles. It could make those with a weak stomach for gore queasy from time to time.

 

I didn't feel like any of this was particularly gratuitous. To me it feels like a movie that is intended for the maturity that comes with experiencing life.

Spirituality

While this is not a Christian movie specifically, religion plays an important part. Wallace and his kin speak reverently of God on multiple occasions. When they say “Christ” in this movie it's not a flippant profanity, it is an invoking of the Savior. Even Stephen for all his irreverence, foul language, and crazy antics gives the impression (at least to me) of having a real faith.

 

Wallace does not live a sinless life. We see him have an affair with a married woman, and he most definitely takes bloody vengeance for wrongs committed. Likewise for the husbands of the raped wives. But these heroes aren't seeking out evil. William in particular goes to lengths to live peacefully until he has little choice but to either roll over and die or get out from under the boot heels of these evil men. How would you react if you saw your spouse murdered for refusing to be raped? I might have a hard time resisting getting stabby myself.

Final Thoughts

This is a fantastic, moving story that everyone needs to see at least once. Even with its questionable content the positive themes are strong enough for me to recommend this to teens old enough to appreciate it beyond the glimpses of boobies and bloody, severed limbs.

Buying Guide

I hope to upgrade my "Braveheart" DVD to the Blu-ray eventually, but for now I'll tell you what I can about what I know.

 

There are a couple of DVD versions, and mine is the oldest since I grabbed it up as soon as it was released. So, sadly, my buying guide is going to be lacking details on the better releases. The original DVD offers very little beyond the movie. The other DVD is a 2 disc “Special Collector's Edition” and appears to have the same movie presentation with several additional extras.

 

The Blu is a 2 disc package as well. The HD video is 2.35 widescreen at 1080p with 5.1 Dolby HD surround sound. The presentation gets nearly perfect marks from reviewers I've check out so count on great quality. Exact details on the extras have been sketchy, but there is definitely a good bit here. It offers some “interactive timelines” which appear to essentially be behind the scenes features that take advantage of Blu's advanced technology. One is said to deal with the movie production, one covers the historical story, and the last looks at the fictional story. There's a new set of cast interviews and a couple of features that appear to visit some of the historical locations we see in the movie. Gibson's commentary is here, and at least some (maybe all) of the DVD extras are present. There is a steelbook case variation available as well.

 

And if you're a Gladiator fan you can pick up a 2 Blu or DVD pack. The Blu says it's a 4 disc set and so probably includes all the extras. The DVD appears to be the older DVD version. There are other multi-packs out there, but I won't try to go through them all.

 

Final Recommendation:

I've thought this move worth owning purely on its own merits so that I can watch it whenever the mood strikes me. I'm intrigued by the historical features offered on the Blu and hope to be revisiting my guide with more info about them eventually. The Gladiator 2 pack looks like it could be a good buy.

The original Widescreen Collection DVD is out of print according to what I read so they may be harder to come by as time goes on.

 

Video

2.35:

This looked great back when I was upgrading from VHS. Now it looks rough. It's not as sharp as it could be, the colors look flat and dull, it's rather pixelated, and there is minor but noticeable trash.

Audio

5.1 Dolby:

The sound is clear with just enough bass to appreciate it. The surround sound immersion is not bad.

 

Packaging

The case is standard plastic.

 

It has an insert that contains several images, some brief plot notes, and a chapters list.

 

The interface is simple with a static image and basic menu.

 

Extras

-Commentary: Mel Gibson: This is surprisingly interesting. I mean how great can one guy talking for 3 hours be?  It’s slow at times, but he offers some insight into the true history of Wallace as well as various aspects of the movie-making experience. I’ve listened to it twice and enjoyed it both times. I haven't seen the commentary listed in the features for the other releases (though I haven't seen the releases themselves). I don't know why they wouldn't include it, but exclusions like that do happen.

 

-The Making of Braveheart (28:07) The behind-the-scenes video starts out with a lot of just telling the story but finally gets into some good, original material.  The other releases have behind the scenes features listed, but I can't say for sure if they're the same one.

 

-Theatrical Trailer 1 (1:41) Showing off the romance and action.

 

-Theatrical Trailer 2 (2:56) Similar to the other but with an announcer.

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page