top of page

2

(nothing direct)

4

8

(the best of its kind)

(nudity, sexuality, strong language, violence, disturbing concepts)

"Silence of the Lambs" was the first movie I ever bought for myself back when VHS was king. Some consider "Manhunter" to be the best serial killer movie made, but this Jon Demme outing gets my vote. It's spooky, in a darkness-of-human-nature kind of way, disturbing, and fascinating. I guess you could say Hannibal Lecter is not that far removed from Jason, Freddy, or Mike Myers, but Hannibal is more realistic and therefore more frightening.

 

When a killer leaves a trail of mutilated bodies but precious few clues for the FBI to follow the investigators resort to seeking insight from the most brilliant serial killer mind in captivity, Hannibal “the Cannibal” Lecter. Clarice, a young rookie agent, is recruited to gain Lecter's confidence, but he is not one to help out with altruistic motives; he wants inside Clarice's head while achieving his own ends. Clarice finds herself entwined with two hyper-intelligent psychopaths who love to play games with others’ lives which releases inner demons to torment her mind. She will have to battle the external and internal evils if she is to save Buffalo Bill's latest victim from a gory fate.

 

One thing that makes this story so much better than others is that such emphasis is put on the psychology. The killer doesn’t mindlessly slaughter people like a slasher film, he has purpose and a goal. This is scary because for all his inhuman actions he is not some undead monster nor influenced by chemicals or supernatural forces. He’s a twisted human being and maybe your quiet next door neighbor.

 

The movie follows the book impressively well. There are changes, of course, but they are typically minor adjustments like taking away Jack Crawford’s personal problems so that the focus remains on Clarice and the killers. We do lose the background on Buffalo Bill which is unfortunate.

 

One major change is the nature of Hannibal. In the book he’s more along the lines of using tricks to make people think he’s smarter than he actually is. Not that he’s not still brilliant, but it’s more of an ego-boosting exercise. For instance he reveals something about an element of Buffalo Bill’s life which greatly impresses Clarice. Crawford later reveals that this is a standard deduction with the evidence given stealing a great deal of Hannibal’s thunder. The movie version is much more along the lines of an evil god amusing himself at the expense of mortals.

 

The movie doesn’t explain the details of the evidence as clearly as the book. I think this is actually one reason I liked it initially. The viewer has to contemplate the evidence and pay attention to subtle clues given in order to keep up with the logic of the investigation. Why is the victim’s closet important? Why is Crawford in the helicopter going to where he is going? What is the significance of what we see in the killer’s bathtub? I had to watch it more than once in order to unravel everything, and I enjoyed having to think about it. I could see that not being a positive for all viewers, though. If you prefer everything laid out before you clearly and concisely you may not enjoy the story as much as I do.

 

Two movies cover the events prior to Silence of the Lambs: Red Dragon and Manhunter. I’ve reviewed both. One comment I made was that if someone could combine the story content of Manhunter with the production quality of Red Dragon they would have a tremendous movie on their hands. Watching Silence of the Lambs again I realized that’s exactly what we have here. The plot is thick and solid, the emotion and mood carefully crafted, the cinematography and sound expertly handled. Silence of the Lambs contains the best of both worlds. It doesn’t rely on the shock value the way Hannibal does (not to mention the story is just plain better), it gets the plot points across better than Red Dragon (without feeling as forced I might add), and it looks and sounds prettier than Manhunter (which could have otherwise been this movie's greatest rival).

 

The acting is great all around. Anthony Hopkins is iconic as Hannibal and is no doubt the main reason we eventually got more movies about the character. I don’t think he ever quite nailed the role as well as he did here. Jodie Foster is great as Clarice though some people are put off by her attempt at a Southern accent. It never bothered me personally. Ted Levine as Buffalo Bill is scary and perfectly psychotic. He really doesn’t get enough credit. One of the most fascinating bits in the DVD extras is hearing about Ted’s research for the role and how it affected him.

 

From beginning to end this is a chilling and well crafted movie. If you haven’t seen it but enjoy Seven, Saw, or any of the other thrillers that begin with the letter “S,” not to mention the other Hannibal Lecter movies you should check this one out.

Morality

This is a mature show. There’s a little bit of nudity, but it’s not normal stuff; it’s naked corpses and a guy standing in front of a camera with his wedding tackle tucked between his legs to make himself appear more feminine, not at all sexual. We get a glimpse of a guy's bare butt in another sightly more sexual but disturbing scene.

 

There’s no sex, but there is sexual content, some of it graphic. The naked guy I mentioned is masturbating and flings his bodily fluids at Clarice. He makes a crude comment about her genitals which she repeats to Hannibal. Hannibal makes crude remarks about Clarice's boss having sexual fantasies involving her. He later discusses another woman's nipples. We get some background on the killer's sex life, perversions, and hang ups.

 

We see little as far as acts of graphic violence, but we see a great deal of the disturbing aftermath. There are partially skinned and decomposed corpses, eviscerated victims, a preserved head, and people with mauled faces. Much of the dialogue is disturbing and is graphic in describing murder, mutilation, and cannibalism. Hannibal's nickname is “the Cannibal,” and we hear about his human meals on several occasions both from him and from others as they recount the atrocities he committed. We find out what's being done with the missing skin of the victims with a glimpse of the results, and it is quite disturbing. A woman is held in captivity and terrorized by the killer as he preps her for the slaughter.

 

The strong language is more or less typical for an R rated movie. While there's a lot of it, it doesn't feel excessive with the possible exception of a few scenes that are meant to be disturbing or intense. At the same time a lot of the uses of its are particularly crude, and much of the dialogue, while not necessarily including profanity, is graphic and disturbing in other ways.

Spirituality

Hannibal is approached with the kind of awe and reverence that might be attributed to a deity. He is almost supernatural in his genius and ability to manipulate people. Having said that, though, there is nothing actually supernatural here at all. We touch the insanity of the darkness in men. We know that we wrestle not against flesh and blood, yet still there is something chilling about the things people can do to each other even when presented in this kind of fictionalized tale.

 

At the same time, as deified as Hannibal is we see him caged like the criminal he is. Despite Buffalo Bill's elusiveness we see the investigation closing in on him. These kinds of moments instill a hope that evil can be stopped. It may take a toll on those it touches, but it is not all-powerful. In a spiritual sense this translates into “greater is He who is in us than he who is in the world.” In a physical sense it offers hope that those who would hurt us can and will be stopped.

Final Thoughts

This is a terrific thriller for anyone looking for one to watch. Intelligent, gripping, and beautifully done it’s well worth seeing. It may be overly gruesome for sensitive viewers, but if you can handle detective shows that deal with murder then you can probably handle what you'll get in "Silence of the Lambs."

Buying Guide

The release of “Silence of the Lambs” on DVD has been marred by the unwillingness of any studio to gather and release all of the hard-to-find features of past out-of-print editions. There is no truly definitive edition though that's not to say that there isn't a good one.

 

There are a couple of different Blu packages. One is the Blu by itself, and another offers a DVD along with it. You can find it in The Hannibal Lecter Collection (also on DVD) and as part of a couple of other package deals.

 

DVD offers several different options. First was the Criterion Collection which contains extras not available anywhere else. A single disc release that appears to be bare-bones has widescreen and full screen options. The Special Edition also offers widescreen and full screen and includes some extras. The biggest DVD package is the 2-disc Collector's Edition which has been repackaged once or twice. There are a few different multi-packs (usually with "Hannibal" and "Manhunter") as well.

 

Here are a few more researched details on the editions I don't have before I get to the main details.

 

Blu-ray:

The Blu offers 1.85 widescreen at 1080p with 5.1 DTS HD surround sound. The presentation quality is reportedly fair but probably only a slight upgrade from DVD. Extras include more or less everything that comes with the Collector's Edition DVD. There is one Blu exclusive: a picture-in-picture feature called “Breaking the Silence” which contains some new interview segments with the actors and screenwriter as well as some FBI facts and stuff like that.

 

Other DVD's:

The Criterion Collection DVD is out of print and can be pretty pricey. It offers 1.85 widescreen and 2.0 Dolby surround sound, but the quality of both is said to be lacking. It's also non-anamorphic. It includes a commentary by the director, stars, screenwriter, and an FBI agent which I have heard is quite good.  There are a few deleted scenes, storyboards, an FBI manual, and some statements from real-life serial killers.  Little if any of this is available anywhere else.

 

The Special Edition offers both ratios.  I read somewhere that the earliest pressings included both ratios on opposing sides while later ones split them into different discs. It contains deleted scenes, some outtakes, a photo gallery, and a couple of behind the scenes features including a newer one and an original one.  These are features that are offered with the 2-disc edition but are not as numerous.

 

I've seen two packaging variations of the 2-disc Collector's Edition DVD. Later pressings appear to omit the slipcase (and may also omit the recipe cards). The other, an anniversary release, includes an exclusive art-deco cover that looks pretty nice. From what I could tell by looking at the package it looks like the edition is the same right down to the cover art just with an extra art card on top of it. This card is also available with the Blu.

 

Collections:

The DVD 2-pack with “Misery” sounds like a poor release. At least one reviewer says the quality is so bad he would have thought this was a bootleg. He also says “Silence Of The Lambs” is “full screen” even though it looks like it's supposed to be widescreen.

 

The Hannibal Lecter Collection with “Hannibal” and “Manhunter” does not get much praise, either. It sounds like you can expect “full screen” formatting of at least some of the movies included. There is a book included, but reviewers say there are no other extras.

 

Final Recommendation:

The Blu is not likely to give you a huge quality boost, so it's probably not worth any extra money to upgrade if you already own it, but it might be worth considering if you're looking to buy it for the first time. The Criterion DVD offers a few exclusive extras that die-hard fans might want to check out, but as a whole the package doesn't offer as much for your money as some of the others. The Collector's Edition offers the recipes that I haven't seen offered anywhere else as well as the best quality and collection of extras offered on DVD. Check out the single disc DVD's only if you're wanting to get this as cheaply as possible. I would stay away from the multi-movie packs that are out there. None of them sound like they would be worth the money.

It's time to tell you all about the Collector's Edition DVD which is a 2 disc set.

 

Video

1.85 widescreen:

The image is sharp and clean with strong detail. There's room for improvement, but I have no complaints.

Audio

5.1 Dolby:

The mix is strong with great range and clarity. The surround sound is solid.

 

Packaging

The packaging is a plastic case in a cardboard sleeve (which may not be included in later pressings).

 

On the back side of the insert is a chapters list.  Inside are two pages of production notes providing an interesting read. There are other printed extras I'll tell you about in a moment.

 

The interface includes some fitting animation and dialogue from the film.

 

Extras

 

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page