top of page

2

(nothing substantial)

7

(some superhero violence)

6

(worth seeing more than once)

I can’t think of very many cartoon series that have gotten a theatrical movie treatment. "Mask of the Phantasm" which is directly spun off of the Batman Animated Series of the 90's was an ambitious enough project to warrant such a release. It’s probably the best animated Batman story I’ve seen although I thoroughly enjoyed the "Return of the Joker" movie in the Batman Beyond series and the more recent "Under the Red Hood." In all three cases the writing is more mature even if straddling the fence of being aimed at younger viewers.

 

"Mask of the Phantasm" is certainly not the only Batman interpretation to be dark and melancholy, but it reaches to new depths in the realm of cartoons originally aimed at younger audiences. The cartoon series tends to keep a certain levity. Not so with the movie. It may not be as darkly gothic as Burton's movies or as disturbing as Nolan's, but it’s probably one of the most somber of any released. That says something about it there. Most movies, much less cartoons, can't trigger an emotional response as strongly as this does.

 

This is a look at Batman’s past covering some of the same ground as "Batman Begins" though without the journey and training. It’s Bruce conceiving the idea of Batman and how close he comes to letting love change his destiny when he finds a woman he wants to marry. We all know Batman is a loner so I don’t think I’m giving any secrets away by saying much of the melancholy factor comes from love being denied him. Andrea accepts his marriage proposal then vanishes. Years later she returns to complicate Bruce’s life more than any villain.

 

That’s the character part of the story. The action part is that someone is killing mob bosses, and Batman is targeted as the culprit. The Phantasm alone is a match for Batman, but he must face the new villain in addition to the police who think he is guilty along with an old and dangerous foe. In order to stop this killer Wayne must unravel the mysteries of his past – a painful emotional journey.

 

The cast brings in regulars Kevin Conroy as Batman and Mark Hamill as Joker, plus Dana Delaney, Stacy Keach, and other recognizable names. Between the writing and acting it’s easy to forget that you’re watching a cartoon. The realism brought to the images and characters almost creates an illusion of live action.

 

I enjoyed the Batman cartoon series of the 90’s but I didn’t get so into it that I have made it a priority addition to my DVD collection. "Mask of the Phantasm" was a different story; I couldn’t wait to get it. The emotion and exploration of the Batman character make this well worthy of any Batman fan’s collection.

Morality

There’s some violence beyond the normal Saturday morning cartoon, and some mild, implied sensuality. There is no strong language at all.

Spirituality

There is nothing religious or directly spiritual here although for a while Phantasm appears to be bordering on supernatural. This is a story of loss and sacrifice which gives it its melancholy, even depressing, mood. This is not something that is uplifting. However, it does have the strength of a message that the decisions we make have consequences. They affect those around us, not just ourselves, and there are positive and negative ways to deal with them.

 

Final Thoughts

If you don’t watch any other Batman animation you should watch this one. Although I enjoyed some of the others as well none have the emotional impact and depth that this one has. This is an absolute must-see for every Batman fan or anyone that appreciates a well told somber story.

Buying Guide

There are 2 DVD listings for this title that I've seen although the only difference that I can find is the packaging: one uses the old cardboard case and the other is the sturdier plastic case. There are a couple of combo packs available including a double-feature with "SubZero" and a 3 pack with "SubZero" and "Return of the Joker." There is a mini DVD available as well. There is no high-def option currently.

 

As far as I can tell the contents of the disc in all of these releases are exactly the same (just different packaging), except that the "SubZero" double-feature may offer only the pan-&-scan rather than the widescreen ratio.

 

Final Recommendation:

This is a release that has very little to offer. You won't be missing out on anything if you decide to rent/stream rather than purchase the disc.

The stand-alone DVD release is a single disc with 2 sides – a different aspect ratio is on either side.

 

Video

1.85 & 1.33:

Flip the disc over to see it in the other ratio (widescreen or pan-&-scan). It's pretty grainy with a fair amount of trash. While this is a matted widescreen it is anamorphic which means it looks like it should on a wide screen.

Audio

2.0 Dolby:

This could have benefited from 5.1 surround, but the audio is clean and clear though not particularly strong. There is a little bit of fill in the back channels. The bass is not totally absent but isn't much to speak of.

 

Packaging

The original case, as I said above, is the cardboard variety. I'm pretty sure it's been repackaged in plastic.

 

It includes a chapters list on the inside flap.

 

The interface is very simple with just a static image of the cover art and a music loop. The chapters menu only allows the selection of every few chapters.

 

Extras

-Theatrical Trailer (1:02) A short trailer that seems rather weak in the animation department.

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page