top of page

2

(nothing substantial)

6

(violence and torture)

6

(worth seeing more than once)

To have any appreciation for "Batman Beyond Return of the Joker" you need to be up to speed on "Batman Beyond" the series (at least the pilot). If you don't know about it you might want to check out my Season 1 review for some in-depth info or my review for "The Movie."

 

Basically it's Batman in the future. Wayne is an old man, and the young Terry has taken up the fight under the mentoring of the older hero. The series has dealt with futuristic incarnations of many of the classic Batman villains: Mr. Freeze, Bane, and others. Perhaps one of the most interesting aspects is the influence of the Joker in the form of a gang called the Jokerz but without an actual Joker character.

 

The series has left in mystery what may have happened with the clown prince of crime and has hinted that Batman may have taken off the mask due to old age, but something else broke his spirit. There's also bad blood with him and Commissioner Barbara Gordon AKA Batgirl. Terry has been briefed on Batman's enemies, but the crime fighter’s past and this one nemesis are shrouded.

 

"Return of the Joker" is "Batman Beyond's" crown. It's the revelation of the mystery hinted at for so long. It brings in Batman's most notorious villain, and weaves a tale of a final clash between giants that destroyed all involved. Other Batman tales have suggested that Batman and Joker would be the end of one another, and this story takes a look at how that could happen making it a challenging and epic tale befitting all of Batman lore.

 

The earlier Batman series and this one are bridged in this movie. Terry's life is the present; "Batman the Animated Series" (the show from the 90's) with its style and cast is the past. This helps the flashbacks to feel familiar while wrapping up the original series for its fans. The best part about this meld is while there is a similarity in style, there is a feeling of watching two different shows. Watching the flashbacks feels like watching the other series due in large part to it being so well established already. This, in turn, helps the stories of past and present feel rounded.

 

The present story doesn't quite have the emotional punch that the flashback story has, but it's not bad and is an excellent vehicle for the tale of the past. It's also a creative, if far-fetched, way to work in Batman's original nemesis into this new continuity as well as take a look at some older players like Tim Drake and what their lives are like so many years later.

 

Kevin Conroy returns as the voice of Bruce and Will Friedle as Terry. There aren't very many characters from the "Batman Beyond" series, though. The movie introduces a lot of new faces and focuses on bringing in some from the earlier series: Tara Strong as Batgirl, Matthew Valencia as Robin, Arleen Sorkin as Harley Quinn, and Mark Hamill as Joker. There are several notable guest appearances as well including Dean Stockwell, Melissa Joan Hart, Michael Rosenbaum, Henry Rollins, Rachael Leigh Cook, and others.

 

One of the most interesting things about this story is how disturbing the Batman-Joker showdown is. There's death, mutilation, and conspiracy the likes of which you are unlikely to find in a cartoon oriented for kids. I guess that's why there is a censored version. I'm sure the writers could have gone more extreme if they had really wanted to, but they didn't hold back in creating a sequence of events that was powerful enough to alter Batman's life.

 

As I've said the present story doesn't carry the same power that the flashback story has, but the latter is strong enough to support the entire movie. The acting is good, and the soundtrack is solid enough that I keep tracks from it in my iTunes playlist. As far as animated Batman movies go I would rank this high among the best ones I've seen.

Morality

What you get depends on which version you get. The first release is more kid friendly while the uncut version is PG13. For the most part the primary differences between them are fights which have been cut down so that there are fewer punches shown, deaths we see in one have been mostly moved off screen in teh other, the disturbance factor of the showdown is sugar-coated, and colors are altered to not be confused with blood even when it's not actually blood. In short the uncut version is a bit more violent and disturbing with fighting and murder. And when I talk about it being disturbing take heed if you are thinking of letting your youngster watch this. There is violence, torture, and murder along with a conspiracy to hide misdeeds.

 

There is no strong language or sexuality although some of the girls wear some skimpy clothes.

Spirituality

Like the "Batman Beyond" series as a whole there is nothing religious and very little that approaches any real spirituality. There is something of a theme of what lying to cover your tracks can do to you. It's certainly not approached from a Christian standpoint like the Larry-Boy movie, but there's still a tinge of the kind of darkness sin can bring into a life even when it involves good people.

Final Thoughts

This is a must see for "Batman Beyond" fans. Batman fans that aren’t so fond of or haven’t seen the newer series may still enjoy "Return of the Joker" for the classic Batman story, but they will miss out on who Terry is and what his relationship with Bruce is like. I think it’s on par with the "Mask of the Phantasm" movie. If you’re getting it for a younger viewer the edited version may be your best choice. If, like me, you’re an older viewer, definitely watch the uncut version.

Buying Guide

If you read the "Return of the Joker" review you might remember that there are two versions of the movie. When deciding on which release to get you'll need to keep that in mind along with the various format and combo options.

 

This is the only "Batman Beyond" release offered on Blu. On regular DVD are the edited PG and the uncut PG13 versions. There is a 2 pack with "Mystery of the Batwoman," another with "The Batman vs. Dracula," and a 3 pack box set.

 

This movie is not listed as being a part of the "Batman Beyond" series box set.

 

Blu:

The Blu includes the uncut version of the movie. You may be able to get this with or without a DVD copy. The video is 1.33 (the TV standard ratio). Here's your alternative to the widescreen. This is the original filming ratio even though it was framed for a widescreen presentation. It is 1080p and is said to look quite good. The Audio is 5.1 DTS HD surround sound. Reviews suggest that the sound is strong and solid. It appears to have exactly the same extras as the DVD which I will detail below.

 

PG DVD:

While I have seen both the PG and PG13 versions myself I don't have the PG version available for side-by-side comparison. I didn't notice any differences between them whatsoever aside from the movie itself (covered in the review if you want more details).

 

Combos:

The DVD movie combo packs contain the edited PG version according to comments I've read so don't get them if you want the uncut version. The 3 pack is a 3-disc package which means it probably includes the full version of the release, extras and all.

 

I didn't see a listing for the extras with "Mystery of the Batwoman" but would be surprised if it didn't contain the full compliment as these Warner 2 packs tend to include the full release of each film on either side of a double-sided disc.

 

The pack with "The Batman vs. Dracula" definitely includes all extras for both releases, but I don't know if "Return of the Joker" is the uncut version or not (my guess would be not since the others aren't).

 

Final Recommendation:

The rating you prefer is the main decision point here since there is little if any difference in the DVD design or extras. If you want the PG version that is going to rule out the Blu; if you want uncut then avoid the combo packs. It sounds like the quality upgrade is worth a little extra cash for the Blu.

The Original Uncut Version is the PG13 edit and is a single disc DVD offering.

 

Video

1.66 NA widescreen:

While it was filmed at 1.33 it was framed for widescreen so this is how it was intended to be seen. The image is fairly clean although it sounds like the Blu version would be a noticeable upgrade. There is a little bit of trash, but it's almost unnoticeable unless you're really watching for it. Unfortunately the ratio presentation is non-anamorphic so it will not fill a widescreen TV (black bars appear on all sides of the image).

Audio

5.1 Dolby:

Surround sound surprised me a little since I only expected 2.0. The sound is clean and strong with fair surround sound immersion. It's not highly impressive, but it's not bad at all. There seems to be surprisingly little bass considering the series episodes sound pretty solid in that regard.

 

Packaging

The original package was one of those awful cardboard cases though I believe that has been phased out for the typical plastic case.

 

While the cardboard version does not come with an insert there is a chapters list on the inside flap.

 

The interface is unremarkable but colorful featuring the cover art, some music clips, and some original graphics.

 

Extras

-Commentary: Producer, writer, director, art director: It’s very informative covering the difficulties of doing a movie and a TV season, where the new characters came from, differences in the Joker from the original, toning down the gruesomeness, casting Angie for Barbara Gordon, revisiting “Batman the Animated Series,” Harley's fate, and Joker's new look.

 

-Animatics (3:22) This is more like a storyboard slideshow with music and some voices.  There are 3 scenes shown this way as 1 long clip.

 

-Beyond Batman Beyond Documentary (12:01) The behind-the-scenes feature is basically a long promo with very little new information. There are a few good moments with the acting and musical talent, but it could have been better.

 

-Video Character Bios (4:56) The character files are animated so you have to go along with its pace and read quickly. It’s an OK feature if you’re new to Batman Beyond, but I think most long-time fans will find it kind of boring. There’s not really any new info here. Use chapter stops to skip between characters.

 

-Confidential Bat Footage (5:20) This is a deleted scene in the form of a storyboard.  The art is pretty basic, but you do get some voice acting with it.

 

-Bat Trivia: The trivia section is a game but there is no final score or prize for winning, just get the questions right or don’t.

 

-Music Video:

-Crash - Mephisto Odyssey and Static X (3:51) The song is OK, but the imagery is what I like. They are performing in the Batcave with a dance party that looks like it could be from the club Terry and Dana frequent.

 

-Return of the Joker Teaser (1:46) Shows off the darkness of the Joker.

 

-Previews: A few Batman and Scooby-Doo titles presented in a menu.

 

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page