top of page

5

(mythological religions, positive comments about church and scripture, a Bible-waving tyrant)

6

(nudity including full frontal, occasional sexuality, sparse strong language, violence)

7

(worth seeing and revisiting)

Note that this will spoil the ending of the Stargate movie.

 

Who knew that when the movie "Stargate" came out that it would eventually spawn one of the longest running sci-fi series ever? The movie wrapped everything up pretty nicely, Ra is dead, Daniel is on Abydos with his wife, the team makes it home, Jack is no longer suicidal. If there were no additions to the story it would be a fine ending. However, finding an extension to the story really isn’t that difficult: make the stargate open to other worlds and put some more aliens out there. Executing that may not be so easy, but SG-1 pulls it off almost perfectly.

 

The Stargate program has been shut down. With the threat gone and the gate on the other side shut down there’s not much more to do. What Earth doesn’t know is that there is another god out there who is now able to access the Earth gate. Apophis is looking for a queen and takes an Air Force soldier from Earth as well as Daniel’s wife from Abydos. Daniel and Jack reunite to fight this new threat and are joined by the beautiful Captain Samantha Carter and later by the tank Teal’c, a soldier of Apophis who wishes freedom for his people.

 

As Earth learns of the immense number of alien races on the many worlds out there and the threat of Goa’uld attack from space they begin an exploratory commission to make allies and retrieve helpful technology. SG-1 is the most experienced team, but there are many others exploring also.

 

Part of what makes this show so fun is the immensity of it. There is so much in the Stargate universe to explore. The possible stories are endless. SG-1 has its flaws, but it does such a fantastic job of creating an epic-scale mythology that fans are able to immerse themselves in it. We get to revisit or at least reference what came before so there is a strong feeling of progression which really feels rewarding for the faithful viewer.

 

Another important element is the core set of characters and the fantastic portrayals of them. Michael Shanks does such a good job of filling the shoes of James Spader that transitioning from the movie to the show version of the character is almost seamless. OK, maybe that’s an exaggeration, but it’s still easy to swallow. Richard Dean Anderson as Jack is a bigger change, but it helps that he went through such a big transition at the end of the movie. Jack is surprisingly funny now, but still very serious about his job. He’s not book smart compared to others on his team, but he’s an impeccable leader, dealing with pressure with the resolve of a super hero. I used to watch MacGyver some, but I never knew how good an actor Richard is until I saw some of the very out of character positions his character gets into. Sometimes I think the writers try to come up with the most outrageous things to happen to Jack just because it’s so much fun to watch Richard portray them.

 

There are some guest appearances by other movie characters with some of the movie actors returning and some not, but all of the other main characters are new. Teal’c is a human-like alien that carries around a larval parasite in his gut. It provides him with a stronger than normal physique including resistance to disease and injury. Teal’c was in the service of Apophis until he saw in SG1 the chance to free his people from slavery to the Goa’uld. Christopher Judge does a phenomenal job portraying the noble and powerful character showing emotion only subtly beneath his stone face but getting it across nonetheless. Teal’c often has the funniest lines which are all the more so because of the seriousness of the character.

 

Amanda Tapping is the drop-dead gorgeous, freakishly brilliant Sam Carter. While that combination sounds like it should be corny Amanda plays it with the attitude of a soldier scientist not a beauty queen and makes the character seem real.

 

There are many other recurring characters, but two of the most important are the staunch General Hammond and the lovely Dr. Fraiser. Once again, though, despite Fraiser’s looks her portrayal is not built upon that. A lot of times female roles like this can feel like they were created for no greater purpose than having beautiful women on screen. Perhaps if Carter and Fraiser had more of a supermodel air to them or showed up in tight and revealing clothing that might seem like the case here, but I think part of what makes them so attractive is that they don’t try to be beautiful, they just are, like that girl next door you just can’t take your eyes off of.

 

To have a successful series you have to have characters that the viewer wants to spend time with and SG1 does this as well as any show I can think of. These people fight for justice and honor often facing off against the corruption of their allies on Earth as much as the evils of the universe. But you have to have good villains as well. Part of the strength of SG1 is that it doesn't rely on any single villain, for that matter in the long haul it doesn't rely on any one race or idea. Sometimes there isn't a villain at all but a problem to be conquered.

 

Therein lies the interest, the viewer has no idea what's coming. It might be a Goa'uld attack, it might be a bug, it might be a misunderstanding or disagreement with another sovereign race. The variety of stories keep the series from being repetitive. I said the same thing about X Files, and SG1 is the only sci-fi show I can think of to surpass it in the length of its run.

 

Even with great ideas sometimes the execution can stink. One thing that keeps SG1 from falling into that is that it often takes the more difficult road in its solutions (although I do think the healing sarcophagus is over-used for a while). Generally this keeps the endings from being as predictable as many shows. You can't be sure that every problem will be solved, you can't even be sure that anyone but the people in the title sequence will survive (and occasionally not them, either, but that comes later). Even if a problem is solved in the short-term that doesn't mean there aren't more consequences down the road, and vice-versa; an unresolved issue may well be revisited in the future. The point is that the stories continually feel fresh and worth the time to watch.

 

There's generally a lot of fast paced action, but there are also many dramatic and suspenseful moments. Some episodes are slower than others, but they tend to remain interesting, sometimes even more so that the adrenaline-laden moments.

 

Downfalls: there aren't many, and they aren't big. I mentioned the sarcophagus use already. Others include some too off-the-wall characters, sometimes they can just be wild and crazy to the point of being unbelievable. General Hammond occasionally gives into demands from the team too easily, but this is partially alleviated by his obvious high respect for Jack's judgment and improves later on with stronger rebukes for Jack's more emotionally driven rebellious moments and a better setup for the offering of ideas from the team. The phrase "with all due respect" is overused. Some guest actors aren't that great, and sometimes the special effects don't quite look realistic although in most cases you really have to look hard to notice it.

 

One big loss is the language barrier. If you read my Stargate movie review you know that one element I really liked was the realism of a communications barrier. How likely is it that these people would speak our language when many people on our own planet don't? On the other hand, how good can a TV series be if every episode is about learning a new language? It's a sacrifice necessary for a series of 40 minute plots. We do occasionally get a race incapable of linguistic communication and differences in the English that cause confusion. This helps drive home the fact that we're dealing with aliens at times.

 

There are few shows out there worth your precious time as much or more than SG1. It shows the difficulties of life as well as the hope. Much emphasis is put on doing the right thing even when commanded to do otherwise by superiors or captors. It casts much hope on the potential of the human race.

Morality

Despite being developed by Showtime which could allow all manner of questionable material, this series is more family-friendly than many regular TV shows. The most notable exception is in the pilot which features full-frontal female nudity in a pretty long scene. The scene is meant to be disturbing and not at all sexual. Incidentally if you watch the recut piolot, "Children Of The Gods," you can see a version without the nudity.

 

There is very little sexuality, sexual dialogue, or revealing attire with the moments that are depicted handled responsibly. The most notable exception is Hathor who uses sexuality to control the men around her and talks about the pleasures of sex without getting into any explicit detail. The women on the base seduce the men to stop them, but it never gets steamy. Hathor seduces Daniel in a way that could be considered rape. Speaking of which, in another episode, savages attack a woman presumably with the intention of raping her, but they are stopped. O'Neill is lured into bed with a woman (we see virtually nothing of it aside from his getting out of bed while trying to cover his nakedness).

 

Strong language is not common. There are occasionally a few choice words that can't be said on regular TV, but the use of any questionable words at all is infrequent.

 

There is violence and death, but it is generally not at all graphic. We are dealing with war-like conflicts that involve people being shot and infected by alien parasites that usurp a person's will. Some of these scenes can be disgusting and disturbing, but not as a result of blood and guts. We see bloody wounds from time to time but nothing particularly gory.

 

So to sum it up, except for the one nude scene the show generally touches the tamer side of PG13 in my opinion.

Spirituality

"Stargate" deals a lot with religion but tends to mostly stay away from Christianity focusing instead on religions that are more universally held to be mythological in modern society (yes, there are those that consider Christianity no less a mythology than Zeus, but considering that many of us hold fast to our beliefs "Stargate" does not want to alienate us).

 

The notion is that these “gods” were real but actually nothing more than aliens using religion to control the weaker populaces. While that holds true for the series as a whole, this first season does have several mentions of Christian ideas. The notion of going to church comes up, and Carter suggests that she has been a church-goer herself. There are several mentions of people believing in God here on Earth.

 

The main exception as far as individual stories go is “The First Commandment.” The title connects the command “have no other gods before me” to the episode's villain who acts as a tyrannical deity not unlike the Goa'uld in some ways. He is revealed to be a guy who has looked to the Bible for some time in an attempt to “find God” only to come to believe that he himself IS God.

 

The suggestion I see in the character is that though he has been looking in the Bible for truth he has been unwilling to subject himself to a higher authority. The episode stretches a few times to try to include some biblical dialogue that doesn't really fit as well as it should. Most notably is the story of Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac used in a weak explanation of the actions of the natives. When Carter can't bring herself to shoot an unarmed man, O'Neill mentions, in a comically bumbling way, the commandment about murder as a way to support Carter's decision.

 

What I really find interesting about this episode is that Jonas, the villain, justifies his actions with good intentions. It's illustrative of two different points. One is that while his ends may be good (at least on the surface), his means are void of any love and therefore invalidates anything he might be trying to accomplish (1 Corinthians 13). The other is that he is perpetrating evil while thinking he is doing something good. I think this is the way many of us fall: we don't do evil things for the sake of evil, we do them thinking we are doing something positive or at least getting something beneficial out of it for ourselves. Jonas can listen to reason when he is confronted with what it is he is really doing, or he can justify his actions and try to silence the critics.

 

Outside of the specifically religious the stories are ones that celebrate freedom and opposition to tyranny. The question of whether or not violence is an acceptable response comes up occasionally. The heroes of the series are admirable people. They detest corruption, value friendship and loyalty, and aren't afraid to put their lives on the line for the benefit of others.

 

The human race as a whole is not portrayed as noble. There are evil men who would use the power of the stargate and other alien technology for their own gain. Many potential allies don't want to share with us because we will end up destroying ourselves with any advantage we get which is not too far from the truth.

 

Overall, though, the series points to hope for the human race. Granted in this setting it's more of an evolution to a state beyond greed and violence that is our hope rather than following God's commands to refrain from murder, greed, and other sins. And yet there is something uplifting in the idea of hope for humanity.

 

In one episode Teal'c has to face up to things he did as an agent of Apophis. Even though he did what he thought what best at the time he recognizes the pain he has caused. In his nobility he refuses to take the easy way out, and allows himself to be tried for his crimes. It's a powerful story of responsibility and forgiveness. 

Final Thoughts

This is a great show. You don't even need to necessarily be a sci-fi fan to enjoy it. There is so much more here than strange aliens and space battles: drama, excitement, humor, and creative stories. The writing and production will improve from what it is in this first season, but don't let that make you think that the early stories aren't good. With 10 seasons, 3 movies, and a few different spin-offs (all of which I hope to eventually cover on this site) it can get to be a large time investment to go through all of it, but I think it's absolutely worth it!

Buying Guide

The first season of "Stargate SG-1" was originally sold in single disc volumes with the full season being considered a “box set” or “gift set.” That didn't last long. These days you can't buy anything but the whole season.

 

While there is only one actual TVD release there have been a few packaging variations: the full size box (covered in detail below), a slim case box, and a plastic multi-disc case. You can also get this as part of a series box set.

 

Box set:

The Complete Series Collection has some big positives and some big negatives. The upside is a very cool metallic box with a gorgeous Stargate on the front. It appears to contain everything the original sets do plus a guide book, and 4 discs worth of additional bonus features that are too numerous for me to list. The negative is that review after review speaks of horrible disk holders and DVD's damaged to the point of being useless. Since it's going to take a while to go through 10 seasons of episodes and all their features some people found themselves outside of the return policy window with a defective product. This is just too expensive for that.

 

Repackaging:

I don't know all the exact details about the repackaging, but I'll tell you a little of what I do know (because some people are particular about this sort of thing). First was a thin-pack redesign which is very similar to the one I have but uses thin cases that hold more than one disc. The result is that it takes up about half the shelf space as the original design. The newest one is a single plastic case holding all of the DVD's. You'll miss out on some of the cool artwork from the original release, but otherwise it appears to be a shelf-friendly and convenient design. The disc content is exactly the same as far as I can tell.

 

Final Recommendation:

As much as I would like to see all those extra bonus features I think I'll be avoiding the complete series box set. If you don't care about which package variation you get, you can pick up any season 1 set. Some collectors like a uniform look to their shelves so keep in mind that you cannot get all 10 seasons in the original large box packaging although I'm relatively sure you can get them all in either one of the other variations.

No matter which packaging you get, Season 1 is a 5-disc DVD set.

 

Video

1.78 widescreen:

It's grainy and slightly smudgy at times with some jerky frame rates here and there. It's not awful, but it definitely could be a lot better.

Audio

2.0 Dolby:

It sounds clean but somewhat muffled which sometimes makes the dialogue sound more muddled than it should.

 

Packaging

The original packaging is rather large. Each disc has it's own regular sized plastic DVD case with unique cover art on the front, episode summaries with images on the back, and an insert that has the cover art on one side and episodes credits with chapters lists on the other. The cases fit in a big, sturdy box with plenty of Stargate images all over it and an episode and extras list on the spine. The artwork looks great, but this design takes up a lot of shelf space.

 

The interface isn't flashy, but it does include some original artwork that looks good. You'll need to enter the Stargate to access the episodes which then has a view of the embarkation room with various related graphics and sound effects. Each episode has its own set of menus with chapters and settings.

 

The Pilot is the uncensored version that includes the nudity.

 

Extras

 

Episodes

There are 20 episodes at almost exactly 44 minutes each plus the pilot which is a little over an hour and a half. 

 

Chapter division could be better.  Most have 5 chapters which is fine, but chapter 1 ends somewhere well into the story meaning that if you don’t want to watch the opening you have to scan rather than using a chapter skip.  It’s my one gripe about the design.

 

There is no play all option.

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page