top of page

5

(mythological and fictional religions, discussions of God, an alien posing as Satan)

7

(mild violence)

7

(worth revisiting)

Stargate SG1 had me hooked from the first episode when I had the opportunity to watch it from the beginning rather than catching random episodes here and there. Season 2 improved on several elements and expanded the universe. Season 3 continues to hold the line strong with intriguing stories mixing exciting action, engaging characters, and touching emotion.

 

Since I've written reviews about the previous seasons I won't go into the basics so much. If you're a new Stargate fan you can watch and enjoy season 3, but to get the full effect you really need to start at the beginning. SG1 is a progressive storyline with new plots building upon old ones. Sometimes this is a direct continuation of a previous story, sometimes it's just a reference, but either way, the majority of the time what you see will mean more if you know the history.

 

We don’t get as many new additions as we did last season, but we do get a big one: the Replicators. Besides being an impressively dangerous enemy, they will provide a chance for the Tau’ri (Earthlings) to really prove themselves to the Asgard. But I’m getting ahead of the series. I’ll talk more about this in the next review. Suffice it to say that they provide for an exciting season finale.

 

There is only one other notable addition that comes to mind. The concept of ascension was not previously introduced as far as I remember. This will become quite a big deal later on; for now we just get what appears to be a new alien species, but some important groundwork is laid.

 

This season includes a couple of pivotal episodes for some of our recurring characters. If you remember, Daniel’s wife and brother-in-law were both taken as Goa’uld hosts. Their stories are wrapped up. They are not always happy endings either. The writers do not take the easy way out with either one of them creating challenging stories to deal with the situations rather than taking the assumed path. The Harcesis child story arc continues alongside those and provides some of the biggest character moments for Daniel.

 

Pretty much everyone we’ve met before returns this season. Dr. Fraiser is practically a regular at this point. They could really include her in the main titles. Bra’tac, Jacob, Maybourne, Martouf, and even Kawalsky return. The NID, Tok’ra, Tollan, and Asgard play major parts, and the Nox and Unas put in small appearances. Some enemies you probably thought were done for also show up, but I won’t spoil who.

 

If anything is improved this season it might be the effects. Not that they were ever bad, but the Replicators might just be the best work they’ve done so far. We get a great meteor shower, a good-looking battle with invisible adversaries, plus floating objects and beings of light that are perfectly executed.

 

I don’t know that you could possibly improve on the acting abilities of the main and recurring characters at this point. I would put most of these guys up against any dramatic TV show I can think of. The guest actor quality seems to have improved some, though. In fact, Megan Leitch (another X-Files regular putting in an appearance) gives what may be the best performance I’ve seen of her.

 

If I have any real contention with this season it’s the introduction of another Goa’uld on Earth. While it’s fun to watch SG1 have to lay down a smokescreen while dealing with other Earth agencies, the premise for Seth on Earth is weaker than what I have come to expect. Besides, how many Goa’uld can believably be imprisoned or taking refuge on Earth with such silence? We’ve already had Hathor, now Seth, and there are more to come. And that doesn’t take into account the other aliens that are here.

 

Some of the stories are slower than I expected. While they still remain interesting they’re perhaps not as gripping as others. In contrast, though, "Maternal Instinct," which is probably one of the slowest as far as action, is also one of the best as far as story and atmosphere. There’s a lot of mystery and some lovely special effects.

Morality

The series continues to be quite tame as far as questionable content goes. There’s some strong language here and there, but it’s generally sparse and mild with many episodes having none at all.

 

There’s no sex and little if any blatant sexuality. I can’t think of so much as a moment of revealing attire in this season.

 

The violence is generally tame as far as graphic gore but does include plenty of people shooting at each other with lethal consequences. This is countered by the more advanced races making clear the value of life. Some won’t even kill to defend themselves (although don’t let that make you think there is any kind of message here that makes killing to defend yourself out to be an evil thing – if anything it takes the viewpoint that it’s an unfortunate necessity sometimes).

Spirituality

Religion continues to play a big part in the basis of the stories. Many of the mythological gods, usually Egyptian or Norse, are real but are aliens with highly advanced technology rather than actual deities. The series stays away from grouping Christianity in with these ancient religions, but this season does have an episode with a society that resembles medieval Catholicism.

 

The Goa’uld master here is posing as Satan (the team initially thinks he may be posing as Yahweh) while the human spiritual leader manipulates religion for his personal gain. It shows the ability of corrupt religious leaders to manipulate Christian scripture to accomplish evil goals. This is something we have to be wary of in real life. The Bible warns about false prophets and antichrist. Just because a man spouts scripture doesn't mean he's from God.

 

One item of note here is O'Neill's reaction to the possibility that this Goa'uld could be impersonating God. To pose as a mythological deity is no big deal but to pose as God with a capital “G” is “a bit of a stretch” which speaks to the level of power attributed to the Christian deity in comparison to other gods. Further into the season Sokar will return and even show us a Goa'uld rendition of Hell.

 

The introduction of the ascended Ancients suggests that there is more than this physical realm though it isn't quite the same as an explanation for what happens to the soul when we die. They appear to have true power as opposed to advanced technology and are more god-like than the Goa'uld. I'll explore this concept more in future reviews since saying too much here would give away things you might not want to know about the story just yet.

 

One episode deals with the concept of a race having practices that we as humans find abhorrent. They are a kind and generous group of people who do not consider their way of life a negative at all. In fact, they think it an honorable way to survive and grow. SG1 has to decide if they have the right or the obligation to interfere with the free-will practices of a sovereign group. The depth of these kinds of dilemmas is exactly why I enjoy the series as much as I do.

 

The full nature of the real-life application of this concept would take an entire essay to discuss. As Christians we wouldn't want an atheistic society to impose it's desire to have God removed from public life. There are those who advocate for making religious instruction tantamount to child abuse because of the tenants of Hell and damnation, sin and judgment. At the same time we as Christians have faith that we are tapped into the truth of the universe and believe in the scriptures when they tell us that the truth will set us free. We want to share that truth with others and get frustrated when those we care about turn themselves against what we know to be true.

 

Do the atheistic advocates have any right to demand we not teach our beliefs to our children because they don't agree with us? And even if we are right in whatever we believe do we have the right to force someone to make the same claim as a part of some kind of crusade? What kind of faith do you truly have if you make a statement of belief at the business end of a weapon? When you believe something so strongly that the well-being of another innocent person or the eternal ramifications of a decision appears to be at stake then emotions over the matter can run deep. As a Christian just remember that salvation comes through belief in the heart as well as confession with the mouth. You might be able to force a confession but not a heart-felt belief. However, if you can reach the heart then confession will almost certainly follow.

 

Another episode deals with a religion that claims gate travel does not exist as one of their tenants of faith. That can't hold true if SG1 is around to tell the story of how they came through the gate so the religious leaders resort to hiding the truth by any means necessary. These religious types aren't necessarily Christian, but I think they do provide a suitable warning for us. If we think that we have everything figured out to the point at which we would rather bury proof of something that contradicts us rather than seek out truth then are we really seeking out truth at all?

 

That can go the other way as well. There are those who run from the possibility of God even when they see evidence that could point towards him. Yet they will purport to search for truth through science or “free thinking” or whathaveyou. There's a difference between having faith and sticking your fingers in your ears yelling “LALALALALALA!”

Final Thoughts

Stargate SG1 remains one of my favorite TV shows. The Spirituality section of this review is longer than most I've written and only touches on a few of the episodes in this one season. That kind of depth mixed with the fun sci-fi adventure of the stories put this above the average mindless entertainment shows we often get. It’s well done in every way and worth seeing for any fan of science fiction. 

Buying Guide

Like the previous one this first section of the guide for season 3 of "Stargate SG-1" is going to be cover mostly the exact same info as the first one because all the options are the same. I won't repeat all the details, though, so check out the season 1 guide for more.

 

Once again there is one actual TVD release but a few different packaging variations: the full size box (covered in detail below), a slim case box, and a plastic multi-disc case. You can also get this as part of a series box set.

 

The box set offers a good many additional exclusive extras but has a notoriously bad case design.

 

The repackaging options are much more shelf-space-friendly than the original big box. The only tradeoff is the loss of some original artwork. Not all seasons are offered in the big box so if you want all 10 sets to be the same type you'll need the slim-pack box or the multi-disc case.

 

Final Recommendation:

This still isn't as impressive on the extras as some of the future releases will be. In fact, there's really not much here. As much as I would like to see the bonus extras offered by the complete series box set the many reviews of the disc-murdering packaging will stay my hand from clicking that “buy” button. If you want season 3 by itself you just need to decide which packaging you prefer.

No matter which packaging you get, Season 3 is a 5 disc DVD set.

 

Video

1.78 widescreen:

Once again the video quality lacks somewhat. It's grainy and varies a little with some moments looking rougher than others.

Audio

5.1 Dolby:

It sounds clean but somewhat muffled which sometimes makes the dialogue sound more muddled than it should be.

 

Packaging

The original packaging is rather large. Each disc has it's own regular sized plastic DVD case with unique cover art on the front, episode summaries with images on the back, and an insert that has the cover art on one side and episodes credits with chapters lists on the other. The cases fit in a big, sturdy box with plenty of Stargate images all over it and an episode and extras list on the spine. The artwork is great, but the set takes up a lot of space.

 

The interface uses the same image of the embarkation room as the last set. Each episode has its own set of menus with unique art, chapters selection, and settings.

 

Extras

 

Episodes

There are 22 episodes at about 44 minutes each. 

 

Unfortunately, this continues the practice of not putting a chapter stop after the opening credits which means you have to scan through it manually if you don't want to watch it every time.

 

There is still no play all option.

Other Releases Available:
Want to get your hands on something you read about? Click the links below.
Releases Reviewed:
bottom of page